The aftermath was almost as disturbing as the murder itself. McEvoy was tried before a majority-Black jury, but his defense attorney warned his father, Patrick, that calling Robert to testify could damage the revered Gregg family's reputation because of Robert's erratic behavior. The defense also agreed with Mrs. Gregg not to call female witnesses, effectively suppressing potentially explosive testimony about James's conduct toward women working in the mill town. Martha McEvoy later confronted Mrs. Gregg, hinting that she could have testified about the gold piece and suggesting that the Greggs had failed James in some fundamental way. Robert was nevertheless convicted and sentenced to death. While he waited, he posed for a portrait with his amputated legs deliberately kept out of frame, mocking anyone foolish enough to buy his image. He was eventually hanged, while his father—already devastated and living amid poverty and family collapse—was summoned to bury both his wife and son. Historical research by director Richard Pearce and economic historian Tom Terrill uncovered the broader context: a 1875 wage strike, worsening class resentment, and a 1877 petition signed by hundreds asking Governor Wade Hampton to commute McEvoy's sentence. The surviving record never establishes one definitive motive, leaving the case suspended between personal revenge, class rebellion, psychological collapse, and an irreparably abusive social order.
Follow the sources
Status and citations are supplied by the archive. AI concept art is an interpretation, not historical evidence.