What began as a routine vérité project about a New York City “probie,” Antonios (Tony) Benetatos, turned into one of the most consequential pieces of documentary evidence from September 11, 2001. Filmmakers Jules and Gédéon Naudet and FDNY firefighter–filmmaker James Hanlon had been given permission by the department to chronicle Benetatos’s first months at Engine 7/Ladder 1/Battalion 1 on Duane Street. On the morning of 9/11 the crew was split: Jules rode with Battalion Chief Joseph W. Pfeifer to investigate a reported odor of gas at Church and Lispenard, while Gédéon stayed behind to film at the house. Jules famously turned his camera to follow an overhead airliner — capturing one of only three known recordings of American Airlines Flight 11 striking the North Tower. That single frame of film vaulted the project out of a character study into immediate historical record.
The camera didn’t stop there. Jules was allowed to accompany Chief Pfeifer into the lobby of Tower 1 during the frantic response; he and several FDNY chiefs were inside when United Airlines Flight 175 hit the South Tower and when that tower later collapsed. The Naudets, Hanlon and the firefighters fled the lobby and escaped before Tower 1 fell. Meanwhile, Gédéon documented the paralysis at the firehouse as Benetatos learned of the unfolding nightmare on television, later joining retired Chief Larry Byrnes in searching the pile well into the evening. Remarkably, every member of the original squad survived, but the footage captured raw arrivals, communications, and the existential terror of first responders confronting a catastrophe that killed nearly 3,000 people.
The film — produced for broadcast by CBS News’ Susan Zirinsky and hosted in its original airing by Robert De Niro — aired on March 10, 2002, to 39.4 million viewers and later won an Emmy and a Peabody. Its uncensored profanity and unvarnished portrayals of death and rescue triggered an ethical and regulatory debate: the FCC opted not to penalize CBS for indecency, a decision reinforced in practical terms by a 2006 federal appeals court action that temporarily halted stricter FCC enforcement. Beyond awards and ratings, the Naudets’ footage became an irreplaceable primary source — used by historians, journalists, and families — and it helped focus long-term attention on the health fallout among firefighters exposed at Ground Zero. The sequence is not a Hollywood myth but a verified, harrowing slice of history, equal parts journalistic coup and human tragedy.
Follow the sources
Status and citations are supplied by the archive. AI concept art is an interpretation, not historical evidence.