On February 27, 1991, the volatile partnership behind San Francisco’s notorious O’Farrell Theatre ended in bloodshed. Jim Mitchell drove to the Corte Madera home of his younger brother Artie carrying a .22 rifle inherited from their father. Friends and associates had reportedly urged Jim to intervene in Artie’s increasingly destructive behavior, which was linked to alcoholism and cocaine abuse. Inside the house, Artie’s lover, O’Farrell dancer Julie Bajo, was present but did not see the shooting. She heard the gunfire and immediately called 911; police arrived within minutes and arrested Jim. Artie had been shot three times—in the head, abdomen, and right arm.
The case became one of the Bay Area’s most sensational trials, transforming the brothers from countercultural pornography entrepreneurs into national crime figures. Jim was represented by longtime friend Michael Kennedy, who argued against a murder conviction. The jury rejected murder but found Jim guilty of voluntary manslaughter, and he received a six-year sentence. He served approximately three years at San Quentin before returning to the O’Farrell in 1997. The family remained divided over the killing: Jim’s supporters portrayed it as the culmination of Artie’s addiction and erratic conduct, while Artie’s children later called it a premeditated killing motivated by greed and jealousy. Jim died of an apparent heart attack in 2007 and was buried beside his brother.
Follow the sources
Status and citations are supplied by the archive. AI concept art is an interpretation, not historical evidence.