The second Amityville film was born out of a rights dispute rather than a straightforward studio sequel. George Lutz, whose family's alleged haunting at 112 Ocean Avenue had inspired The Amityville Horror (1979), wanted the follow-up to be based on John G. Jones's book The Amityville Horror Part II. Producer Dino De Laurentiis instead secured a deal with American International Pictures to adapt Murder in Amityville by parapsychologist Hans Holzer, producing a loose prequel centered on the fictional Montelli family and the 1974 murders associated with the real DeFeo case. Lutz sued De Laurentiis over the project but ultimately lost, leaving the sequel free to proceed under a different literary source and with no formal connection to the Lutz family's account.
Although the lawsuit failed, Lutz obtained a highly unusual concession: theaters showing the film were required to display posters stating, "This film has no affiliation with George and Kathy Lutz." The disclaimer became part of the film's public identity, underscoring the murky boundary between claimed paranormal history, bestselling books, and fictional exploitation cinema. The production also passed through a complicated corporate chain: it was later acquired by Filmways, which itself was acquired by Orion Pictures shortly before the September 24, 1982 release. The result was a sequel marketed under the Amityville name while publicly distancing itself from the very family whose story had made that name valuable.
Follow the sources
Status and citations are supplied by the archive. AI concept art is an interpretation, not historical evidence.