One of the earliest and nastiest behind-the-scenes battles in animation began when John Randolph Bray, already moving toward an industrial, assembly-line approach to making cartoons, visited Winsor McCay while McCay was creating the landmark Gertie the Dinosaur. Bray presented himself as a journalist interested in the art and was shown McCay's painstaking techniques. Within a short time Bray had begun to patent many of the very methods McCay had developed and then incorporated those techniques into Bray's rapidly expanding studio system. The situation escalated into litigation: Bray attempted to press legal claims of his own but the dispute ultimately favored McCay. Winsor McCay prevailed and, according to contemporary accounts, received royalties from Bray for several years thereafter. The affair left a bitter legacy—exposing how the new, profitable industrial model of Bray's studio could collide with the older craftsman's rights and setting an early precedent about intellectual property in animation just as the medium was becoming commercially significant.
Preparing the daily feature…
AI concept artworkArchive Record · 1910s
The 'Journalist' Who Copied Gertie's Secrets: John Randolph Bray's Patent Fight with Winsor McCay
John Randolph Bray & Winsor McCay / 1910s
One of the earliest and nastiest behind-the-scenes battles in animation began when John Randolph Bray, already moving toward an industrial, assembly-line approach to making cartoons, visited Winsor McCay while McCay was creating the landmark Gertie the Dinosaur. Bray presented himself as a journalist interested in the art and was shown McCay's painstaking techniques. Within a short time Bray had begun to patent many of the very methods McCay had developed and then incorporated those techniques into Bray's rapidly expanding studio system. The situation escalated into litigation: Bray attempted to press legal claims of his own but the dispute ultimately favored McCay. Winsor McCay prevailed and, according to contemporary accounts, received royalties from Bray for several years thereafter. The affair left a bitter legacy—exposing how the new, profitable industrial model of Bray's studio could collide with the older craftsman's rights and setting an early precedent about intellectual property in animation just as the medium was becoming commercially significant.
The daily feature is taking an intermission. There’s still an entire archive to explore.