The 1985 Canadian documentary Artie Shaw: Time Is All You've Got—written, directed and narrated by Brigitte Berman, who had first interviewed the famed clarinetist while making her 1981 Bix documentary—became the center of an acrimonious profit dispute after it achieved far greater success than anyone anticipated. When the film reached its commercial and critical peak by sharing the 1987 Academy Award for Best Documentary Feature (tied with Lee Grant's Down and Out in America) and had already picked up prizes such as first prize at the 1986 Valladolid Film Festival and a Genie nomination, Artie Shaw sued Berman in 1987. Shaw’s claim was blunt: because the picture had outperformed expectations, he argued he was entitled to a larger slice of the film’s profits than whatever arrangement he initially accepted.
What followed was a long, drawn-out legal struggle that stretched across a decade. The dispute moved through Ontario’s courts and culminated in 1997 when the Ontario Superior Court dismissed Shaw’s suit. The case is notable not for lurid allegations but for the rare public confrontation between a legendary subject and a documentarian over monetary entitlement after a film’s unexpected triumph. Despite the litigation, Berman’s film continued to be celebrated and preserved—screened in TIFF Classics decades later, archived for posterity, and ultimately receiving renewed life with theatrical showcases and a Blu‑ray release—leaving the lawsuit as the lasting, very public footnote to the documentary’s success.
Follow the sources
Status and citations are supplied by the archive. AI concept art is an interpretation, not historical evidence.