Krishna Shah repeatedly claimed that his UCLA student short Our Gang won second place in a film competition in which George Lucas’s student film THX 1138 won first. The story created a tempting proto-Hollywood-rivalry narrative, suggesting that Shah had competed directly with Lucas before either became established. The documented timeline, however, undermines the claim: Lucas attended the USC School of Cinematic Arts rather than UCLA, and the original student version of THX 1138 was not publicly screened until 1967, after Shah’s film had debuted at UCLA’s 1966 Talking Pictures program. Shah’s short was praised as the best and most imaginative film of its batch, but the specific competition and Lucas connection are historically unsupported. The episode appears to be a persistent autobiographical embellishment rather than a genuine early rivalry.
Preparing the daily feature…
AI concept artworkArchive Record · 1960s
The Alleged UCLA Rivalry With George Lucas Falls Apart on the Timeline
Krishna Shah / Our Gang / George Lucas / 1960s
Krishna Shah repeatedly claimed that his UCLA student short Our Gang won second place in a film competition in which George Lucas’s student film THX 1138 won first. The story created a tempting proto-Hollywood-rivalry narrative, suggesting that Shah had competed directly with Lucas before either became established. The documented timeline, however, undermines the claim: Lucas attended the USC School of Cinematic Arts rather than UCLA, and the original student version of THX 1138 was not publicly screened until 1967, after Shah’s film had debuted at UCLA’s 1966 Talking Pictures program. Shah’s short was praised as the best and most imaginative film of its batch, but the specific competition and Lucas connection are historically unsupported. The episode appears to be a persistent autobiographical embellishment rather than a genuine early rivalry.
The daily feature is taking an intermission. There’s still an entire archive to explore.
