The long-delayed sequel to Behind the Green Door arrived in 1985 under unusually chaotic circumstances. Instead of reuniting the original film’s professional performers, the Mitchell brothers hired cabaret singer Sharon McNight to direct and filled the production with amateurs recruited through advertisements in Variety and Bay Area sex tabloids. Most of the filming took place inside the O’Farrell Theatre and was completed in only one day. A dancer who had asked to play the lead role of Gloria was considered by McNight, but Artie Mitchell’s girlfriend, who performed under the name Missy Manners, cast herself in the part.
The inexperienced lead reportedly struggled to perform before the crew, creating a tense set. The atmosphere became so strained that Jim Mitchell publicly berated an O’Farrell manager over the quality of the catered lunch. The production was also heavily over budget, costing approximately $250,000, despite its compressed schedule and amateur cast. It is remembered for an odd technical distinction—the men wore condoms and one character delivered safe-sex advice, making it an early safe-sex adult film—but adult publications later described the finished picture as one of the worst pornographic films ever made. The sequel’s failure exposed the danger of trying to reproduce the commercial impact of the original without its professional cast and controlled production structure.
Follow the sources
Status and citations are supplied by the archive. AI concept art is an interpretation, not historical evidence.