In 1974, director Tom DeSimone made Erotikus: A History of the Gay Movie, a documentary-style survey narrated and performed by Fred Halsted. Halsted appears in a director’s chair, progressively undresses, and narrates the evolution of gay pornography from physique magazines and 8mm loops to explicit feature films. The production itself contained an especially strange bit of cinema sleight of hand: when the film reaches its masturbatory climax, a double was used—not for modesty, but because the replacement performer had a larger penis and produced what the filmmakers considered a more impressive ejaculation.
Halsted’s relationship with the film became bitter. He objected after DeSimone reduced his compensation because the double had been used, and he was furious that Erotikus reused a Los Angeles Times headline from L.A. Plays Itself about a “new weird cult” linked to the Tate murders. In Halsted’s view, the documentary’s editing implied a connection between gay BDSM and the Manson killings that his own film had not intended to make. He denounced Erotikus in conversation and in print, turning what might have been an affectionate historical survey into a personal dispute over payment, authorship, and the stigmatizing interpretation of his work. Later versions also omitted the notorious fisting sequence from L.A. Plays Itself, further changing the balance of the material Halsted believed he had contributed.
Follow the sources
Status and citations are supplied by the archive. AI concept art is an interpretation, not historical evidence.