When the 97th Academy Awards nominations were announced on January 23, 2025, a surprisingly public and heated controversy erupted over who should receive the Best Makeup and Hairstyling nomination for the Oscar frontrunner The Substance. The dispute pitted the film's credited hairstylist and make-up artist Marilyne Scarselli against hair designer Frédérique Arguello — with a visible faction of awards-watchers and industry colleagues arguing that Arguello deserved top-billing on the submission. The clash was not merely personal: it exposed raw nerves about how credit is assigned in tight, collaborative departments and about the nomination-submission mechanics that pick a handful of names for a single award. The controversy intensified because, while Scarselli ultimately was listed among the film's Oscar winners, the 78th British Academy Film Awards had already delivered a different form of recognition — Scarselli shared the BAFTA for Best Makeup and Hair with Pierre-Olivier Persin, Stéphanie Guillon and Frédérique Arguello, underlining the fact that Arguello was very much seen by peers as integral to the film’s look. The episode left an uneasy aftertaste in the hair-and-makeup community: a split public record of recognition (BAFTA’s shared credit versus the Academy’s credited winner) that reopened long-standing debates about departmental hierarchy, submission conventions, and who ultimately gets to be named and celebrated on life-changing awards nights.
Follow the sources
Status and citations are supplied by the archive. AI concept art is an interpretation, not historical evidence.