Barbara Kopple’s decision to live with striking families and film the Brookside conflict without voice-over brought her camera into direct contact with violence. From the beginning strikebreakers—derisively called 'gun thugs' by picketers—tried to hide their weapons from the lens; as the strike dragged on guns were openly brandished on both sides. Kopple and her cameraman Hart Perry were physically attacked: contemporary reviews and Kopple’s own accounts describe scenes where the crew were knocked down and beaten while trying to document pre-dawn shootings at strikers. Kopple later revealed in interviews that the head strikebreaker, Basil Collins, even talked about hiring someone to shoot her — and she reported that mine owners hired local prisoners to assault strikers and even fired at houses, forcing families to line walls with mattresses for protection. Paradoxically, several strikers later acknowledged that the presence of the film crew probably reduced the level of shooting and brutality; Jerry Johnson is quoted in the documentary saying the cameras likely 'saved a bunch of shooting.' The hostility toward the production, the physical attacks on filmmakers, and documented death threats make Harlan County, USA one of the most perilous documentary shoots of the era and a stark example of journalism becoming an active participant in a violent labor struggle.
Preparing the daily feature…
AI concept artworkArchive Record · 1970s
Cameras in the Crossfire: Barbara Kopple’s Crew Beaten, Threats to Kill, and Armed 'Gun Thugs' on the Brookside Picket Lines
Harlan County, USA / Barbara Kopple / Hart Perry / 1970s
Barbara Kopple’s decision to live with striking families and film the Brookside conflict without voice-over brought her camera into direct contact with violence. From the beginning strikebreakers—derisively called 'gun thugs' by picketers—tried to hide their weapons from the lens; as the strike dragged on guns were openly brandished on both sides. Kopple and her cameraman Hart Perry were physically attacked: contemporary reviews and Kopple’s own accounts describe scenes where the crew were knocked down and beaten while trying to document pre-dawn shootings at strikers. Kopple later revealed in interviews that the head strikebreaker, Basil Collins, even talked about hiring someone to shoot her — and she reported that mine owners hired local prisoners to assault strikers and even fired at houses, forcing families to line walls with mattresses for protection. Paradoxically, several strikers later acknowledged that the presence of the film crew probably reduced the level of shooting and brutality; Jerry Johnson is quoted in the documentary saying the cameras likely 'saved a bunch of shooting.' The hostility toward the production, the physical attacks on filmmakers, and documented death threats make Harlan County, USA one of the most perilous documentary shoots of the era and a stark example of journalism becoming an active participant in a violent labor struggle.
The daily feature is taking an intermission. There’s still an entire archive to explore.
