Joseph Bottoms was originally hired to play John Eastland, the Vietnam veteran who becomes New York's most grotesque vigilante. Director James Glickenhaus was sufficiently eager to secure the young actor that he sweetened Bottoms's fee with a percentage of the film's profits—an arrangement that could have made Bottoms millions once the independently financed picture became a hit. The gamble became especially painful because Bottoms was also being considered for Disney's expensive science-fiction production The Black Hole, and his representatives feared that a savage exploitation film could damage his image.
Only about a week before photography was scheduled to begin, Bottoms's camp demanded an additional $10,000, arguing that The Exterminator's graphic violence made the deal more dangerous to his career. Although the amount was small compared with the potential profit participation, Glickenhaus viewed the late request as an ambush and refused on principle. Production was delayed for another week while the filmmakers searched for a replacement, ultimately casting Robert Ginty, whose less conventionally heroic physique helped give Eastland a more ordinary and unsettling quality. Bottoms's decision became an especially bitter piece of Hollywood what-if lore after the film reportedly generated tens of millions of dollars in worldwide revenue.
Follow the sources
Status and citations are supplied by the archive. AI concept art is an interpretation, not historical evidence.