After Saving Face won international acclaim — including the 2012 Academy Award for Best Documentary Short Subject and making Sharmeen Obaid-Chinoy Pakistan's first Oscar winner — the film became embroiled in a bitter ethical dispute. One of the survivors featured, identified as Rukhsana, filed a lawsuit alleging that Obaid-Chinoy had promised tangible assistance (money, a new home and plastic surgery) in exchange for participating in the documentary and that she was made to sign blank documents. Rukhsana claimed the publicity from the film led to her husband evicting her and relatives cutting off contact. Obaid-Chinoy publicly refuted the accusations, saying she never promised such aid and noting that Rukhsana had declined offers for Dr. Mohammad Jawad — the London-based Pakistani plastic surgeon who appears in the film — to operate on her. The Acid Survivors Foundation of Pakistan joined Rukhsana in filing a civil suit seeking to prevent the film from screening in Pakistan; despite holding airing rights, Obaid-Chinoy agreed to honor that injunction. The dispute touched off uncomfortable questions about documentary ethics, informed consent, and the responsibility of filmmakers working with vulnerable subjects in conservative communities.
Follow the sources
Status and citations are supplied by the archive. AI concept art is an interpretation, not historical evidence.